Our Japanese students have never had pumpkin pie before so I whipped one up for them to try.
A very harsh, bitter flavor similar to anise was all you could taste. 😩 I thought I had accidentally doubled the spices.
The crust was too good to throw away and the custard innards seemed easy to scoop out...
So I mixed up the filling adding more pumpkin, some cream, more sugar, some vanilla extract, and some almond extract.
This morning I pulled out the tweaked filling. The bad aftertaste remained. I decided to remake the filling altogether.
When I added the lemon extract to the new mix, I noticed it had a harsh smell nothing like lemon. A quick Google search revealed that lemon extract doesn't go bad necessarily, but it can break down into bitter compounds. Ahhh, that explains it.
I dumped the new filling with the bad extract; thankfully I'd only mixed the liquids, not the whole thing. I remade the filling again. Baked it again. Covered the crust with tin foil so it wouldn't burn in the rebake.
This version tasted much better! The girls enjoyed their piece. I was disappointed with the thickness of the crust (which I had wondered about in version 1.0), but otherwise it passed muster. The place where I puzzle pieced the crust together even turned out okay. The filling didn't get underneath the majority of the pie and it was easy to cut and serve.
Now what to do with the original doctored up filling?? Dump? Or add cream cheese to salvage it?
















































